The bizarre theory linking Liverpool gangster Sam Walker with child killer Robert Thompson has now spilled into a larger, and more controversial, debate: Has TikTok itself turned rumor into reality?

What began as a fringe conspiracy on obscure forums has exploded into a viral obsession, driven by short clips, dramatic captions, and an algorithm that rewards controversy.

A digital wildfire

On TikTok, videos claiming Walker is secretly Robert Thompson rack up hundreds of thousands of views. Comment sections become battlegrounds, with some users demanding “justice for James Bulger” while others accuse the theorists of spreading lies.

Clips slowed down to analyze Walker’s accent, tattoos, or body language circulate alongside grainy childhood photos of Thompson — as if internet sleuths are piecing together a true-crime puzzle. But instead of clarity, the result is chaos: a feeding frenzy of suspicion with no evidence.

Walker as “folk villain”

Ironically, the controversy has made Walker more famous than ever. To some, he’s now become a kind of “folk villain” — a symbol of rebellion against authority, basking in the attention of conspiracy theories rather than shying away.

Critics argue this reflects a dangerous shift: crime and scandal as entertainment. For young TikTok users, who may not even know the original details of the Bulger case, the drama plays out more like a digital soap opera than a real-life tragedy.

The ethical nightmare

This raises troubling questions:

Should platforms intervene when speculation targets real people with life-destroying claims?

Does viral fame encourage controversial figures like Walker to embrace — or even exploit — their infamy?

And perhaps most uncomfortable: by chasing these theories, is the public trivializing one of Britain’s most horrific crimes?

A cycle with no end

Even Walker’s furious denials — “You think I’m him? Prove it!” — are now content, clipped and shared thousands of times, ironically fueling the very rumors he wants to crush. The line between denial and performance has blurred so much that every word he says feeds both his fans and his haters.

And that is the true controversy: whether Sam Walker is Robert Thompson matters less than the fact that TikTok has turned speculation into spectacle, and pain into clicks.