You Won’t Believe What’s Coming! The Untamed Season 2 on Netflix Is About to Drop a Plot Twist So Massive It’ll Rewrite the Rules of the Series!

Netflix has officially set the stage for another thrilling chapter in the gripping crime drama The Untamed, with Season 2 confirmed to bring back the intense and brooding Investigative Services Branch (ISB) agent Kyle Turner, portrayed by the ever-charismatic Eric Bana. Following the massive success of Season 1, which dominated Netflix’s English-language TV charts with 24.6 million views in its first week and 26.1 million in its second, fans are buzzing with anticipation for what’s next. But hold onto your hats—this isn’t just a continuation. According to showrunners Mark L. Smith and Elle Smith, The Untamed Season 2 is poised to deliver a plot twist so monumental that it could redefine the entire series and leave viewers questioning everything they thought they knew.

A New Park, A New Mystery

Season 1 of The Untamed captivated audiences with its stunning Yosemite National Park backdrop, where Kyle Turner unraveled the mystery of Lucy Cook’s death, uncovering a web of secrets involving a drug ring, a murder-for-hire plot, and a shocking revelation about Chief Paul Souter, Turner’s mentor, played by Sam Neill. The season’s finale tied up many loose ends, but not without dropping bombshells—like Souter’s suicide and the revelation that Turner’s ex-wife, Jill Bodwin (Rosemarie DeWitt), orchestrated the murder of their son’s killer. These twists left fans reeling and craving more.

For Season 2, the showrunners have promised a fresh setting, moving away from Yosemite to a new national park with a distinct cultural and geographical identity. “We’ve done Yosemite. What’s the next park that could feel different from that?” Elle Smith told Tudum, hinting at a location that will challenge Turner in unexpected ways. This shift could see Turner tackling a case in a park like Yellowstone, Zion, or even Acadia, each offering unique challenges and atmospheres. The park itself will once again act as a living, breathing character, influencing Turner’s emotional journey and the unfolding mystery.

The Game-Changing Twist

While Netflix has kept details under wraps, the buzz around Season 2 centers on a “game-changing” plot twist that promises to upend the series’ established formula. Mark L. Smith teased to Tudum that the new season will place Kyle Turner “on his back foot,” stripping away the confidence he exuded in Yosemite. “Turner was so comfortable in Yosemite,” Smith said. “Now, we’re putting him in a park where he’s stumbling along, finding his way.” This suggests a narrative that will push Turner into uncharted territory, both physically and emotionally, potentially exposing vulnerabilities we haven’t seen before.

Speculation is rife about what this twist could entail. Could it involve a personal betrayal from a trusted ally, like rookie ranger Naya Vasquez (Lily Santiago), who inherited Turner’s horse and station at the end of Season 1? Or perhaps the twist will delve deeper into Turner’s past, revisiting the trauma of his son Caleb’s death, which haunted him throughout the first season. Some fans on platforms like Reddit are theorizing that the twist could involve a supernatural element, a departure from the grounded crime drama of Season 1, though this seems unlikely given the show’s focus on realistic mysteries. Others believe the twist might revolve around a conspiracy within the National Park Service itself, forcing Turner to question the institution he’s dedicated his life to.

What the Cast and Creators Are Saying

Eric Bana, who also serves as an executive producer, expressed his excitement in a statement: “I am absolutely thrilled that we get the chance to bring another season of The Untamed to life. The response to Season 1 has been a testament to the incredible effort by our crew to deliver something truly unique. I can’t wait to take Kyle on his next journey.” His comments to Variety hint at discussions about Turner’s future, suggesting that the character’s nomadic role as an ISB agent—who moves from park to park—sets the stage for a natural continuation.

While Bana is the only confirmed returning cast member, the showrunners have left the door open for familiar faces like Naya Vasquez to reappear. Lily Santiago, who plays Vasquez, told TV Insider she hopes for “new murder, new location, wilderness challenges, and new things to learn” in Season 2, hinting at her character’s potential involvement. However, the shift to a new park suggests a largely new cast, with Mark Smith noting they’ll “populate it with characters that are interesting and help [Turner] in ways both good and bad.”

Fan Reactions and Expectations

The announcement of Season 2 has sparked a frenzy on social media, with fans praising the show’s stunning visuals and Bana’s compelling performance. On Reddit, one user wrote, “I ended up just bingeing it. A few good twists at key points that keep you hooked and thinking back over it and going ‘Ah, I get it now’.” Others have expressed mixed feelings about the Season 1 finale, with some finding the twists—like Souter’s role in Lucy’s death—implausible or rushed. Yet, the promise of a new mystery and a massive twist has reignited excitement.

Critics have also lauded The Untamed, with Rotten Tomatoes reporting an 82% approval rating, praising Bana’s “steady star power” and the “visually sumptuous backdrop” of Yosemite. However, some reviews, like Ben Travers’ C- rating in IndieWire, criticized the show for feeling “familiar” by the end. Season 2’s bold promise of a rule-breaking twist could address these critiques, offering something fresh to distinguish it from other crime dramas like True Detective, which fans have drawn comparisons to for its potential anthology format.

What Could the Twist Be?

While the exact nature of the twist remains a mystery, the showrunners’ emphasis on making Turner “uncomfortable” suggests a deeply personal or professional challenge. Could it involve a case that mirrors his own trauma, forcing him to confront his grief head-on? Or might the twist introduce a new antagonist—a criminal mastermind who knows Turner’s weaknesses? The Smiths have promised that the new mystery won’t simply repeat Season 1’s formula of “someone falling off a mountain,” indicating a shift in tone or structure. Perhaps the twist will involve a moral dilemma, where Turner must choose between justice and personal loyalty, or even a cliffhanger that sets up a larger, multi-season arc.

When Can We Expect It?

Netflix has not yet announced an official release date for Season 2, but assuming production begins in 2025, a Summer or Fall 2026 premiere is plausible, as speculated by Cosmopolitan. The show’s rapid renewal—announced just weeks after its July 17, 2025, premiere—reflects Netflix’s confidence in its staying power, especially after dominating global charts. Fans can expect another six-episode season, maintaining the tight, bingeable format that made Season 1 a hit.

Why It Matters

The Untamed Season 2 isn’t just about solving another crime; it’s about pushing the boundaries of the genre. By moving to a new park and introducing a twist that could “rewrite the rules,” the show aims to keep viewers on the edge of their seats. Whether it’s a betrayal, a personal revelation, or a structural shift to an anthology format, this twist promises to make The Untamed a must-watch in Netflix’s crowded lineup of thrillers. So, mark your calendars and prepare for a wild ride—Kyle Turner’s next adventure is about to shake things up in ways no one will see coming.