LOVE, LAUGHS, AND LATE-NIGHT CHURCH GOSSIP — Amazon Prime’s New Family Dramedy Is Everything You Need

Parents who choose Great American Family or UPtv for wholesome content will want to check out Wonder Project on Prime Video. The new streamer first launched in October 2025, but an all-new original series with a star-studded cast will be premiering this January on the platform.

It’s Not Like That is a family drama that stars Scandal’s Scott Foley, Erinn Hayes and J. R. Ramirez. Here’s everything we know about It’s Not Like That, including plot, release date and an exclusive first look at photos from the new series!

‘Dangerously Obese’: Bryan Struggles to Fit on Airplane After Buying 2 Seats (Exclusive Clip)’Dangerously Obese’: Bryan Struggles to Fit on Airplane After Buying 2 Seats (Exclusive Clip)

What is Scott Foley’s new series ‘It’s Not Like That’ about?

It’s Not Like That follows Malcolm (Scott Foley), a pastor who is a recently widowed dad of three. Lori (Erinn Hayes) is newly divorced with two teens. Their families once did everything together, but now Malcolm and Lori must navigate their newly minted singledom, parenthood and the complexities of Malcolm being a modern-day pastor. Is this the beginning of a love story? It’s not like that. Or is it?

Foley, who is currently guest starring on Will Trent, spoke to Parade about why he decided on taking on a modern family drama, “This is the kind of television that I’m drawn to. There’s no high concept, no one is living in an altered universe/world, it’s just good strong story telling with interesting and complex characters. As a dad of three, I relate to this world to a certain degree and am always looking for an honest and interesting take on the human condition.”

Who created the ‘It’s Not Like That’ drama series?

It’s Not Like That was created by Ian Deitchman and Kristin Robinson, who are best known for Life As We Know It and Parenthood. “It’s Not Like That is a story about hope, and finding light after loss, rebuilding families and exhibiting grace in the most uncertain circumstances,” said Deitchman and Robinson. “There is a powerful dynamic around what we all choose to hold onto when everything around us is falling apart, and how we find our way back—something we hope audiences will relate to and love.”

Who’s in the cast of ‘It’s Not Like That’?

Scott Foley stars as Reverend Malcolm in 'It's Not Like That,' coming to The Wonder Project via Amazon Prime in 2026.

Scott Foley as Malcolm

Foley guest starred on Dawson’s Creek and Step by Step before rising to prominence on Felicity. He followed that up with roles on Scandal and The Unit. More recently, he has starred in La Dolce Vita on Netflix and on ABC’s Will Trent. Foley also serves as an executive producer on the series.

How did Foley approach the role of widowed father and pastor? “I seem to have a bit of a run going in my recent roles, as I believe the last three have been widowers. I lost my mom at a young age, so I have a bit of firsthand knowledge, having watched my father and how he handled that specific aspect of his life at that time. I did a lot of research to understand the role of a minister. I read a few books, and actually reached out to one of the authors, Zack Eswine, a pastor and father himself. We exchanged a few emails, and once he believed I was who I said I was, I hopped on a plane and spent a weekend with him and his family. We ate dinner in his home, and I was even able to attend his church and watch him work on a Sunday in front of his congregation. I spent most days peppering him and his lovely wife with more questions than I think they were expecting!”

Erinn Hayes and Scott Foley in a still from their new series, 'It's Not Like That,' a new series that premieres on The Wonder Project in 2026.

Erinn Hayes as Lori

Hayes is best known for her role as Dr. Lola Spratt on Children’s Hospital. She most recently appeared in Grimsburg, NCIS and The Neighborhood. Other credits include St. Denis Medical, The Good Doctor and The Goldbergs.

J.R. Ramirez is pictured in a still from the upcoming series, 'It's Not Like That,' which premieres on The Wonder Project in 2026. He plays Lori's ex-husband, David, on the show.

J. R. Ramirez as David

Ramirez plays Lori’s ex-husband, David. While Ramirez is best known for his series regular roles on Power and Manifest, his other credits include Pulse, Jessica Jones and Rosewood.

Scott Foley stands behind Leven Miranda, Cary Christopher and Cassidy Paul in a still from 'It's Not Like That.' The three young actors play his children on the show.

Leven Miranda as Flora, Cary Christopher as Justin and Cassidy Paul as Penelope

Christopher, Miranda and Paul play Malcolm’s children Justin, Flora, and Penelope, respectively.

From left to right, actors Liv Lindell, Erinn Hayes and Caleb Baumann are seated in a church pew in a still from the upcoming series, 'It's Not Like That.'

Liv Lindell as Casey and Caleb Baumann as Merritt

Baumann and Lindell play the children of Lori and David.

How to watch ‘It’s Not Like That’ and where is it streaming?

You can watch It’s Not Like That through Wonder Project on Amazon Prime.

What is Wonder Project on Prime Video?

Wonder Project is a subscription service available in the US through Prime Video that offers premium films and tv series for the faith and values audience. It features original content, faith-based films and series—as well as an option for family-friendly “edited versions of movie favorites.” The subscription costs $8.99/month or $89.99/year. There is also a free, 7-day trial available. For additional details, you can visit www.thewonderproject.com.

When is the ‘It’s Not Like That’ release date and premiere schedule?

It’s Not Like That will premiere on Wonder Project on Prime Video on Jan. 25, 2026. The first two episodes will start streaming that day, with new episodes dropping weekly after that. Wonder Project will make the premiere episode available to U.S. Amazon Prime subscribers on Jan. 25 as well. However, a global release date has not yet been announced.