“I DIDN’T SEE THAT COMING” — Love Island: All Stars Star Breaks Silence After Snog, Marry, Pie Shockwave

The game has turned “messier”.

A “messier” game of Snog, Marry, Pie has shaken things up in the Villa as Love Island: All Stars fans were shocked by a twist that saw Helena Ford pieing Belle Hassan.

The Snog, Marry, Pie challenge has always been a popular one with fans and Islanders alike, allowing contestants to let the whipped cream do the talking and get their revenge over unexpected recouplings and betrayals.

Tonight’s episode was no different, expect Love Island producers introduced a change to the usual formula, allowing Islanders to pie anyone of any gender. The tweak led to boys pieing boys, with girls also airing their grievances with one another by way of crust and cream.

Some were shocked by Helena going straight for Belle and delivering the sweet blow, saying: “Pie it to the triangle.”

A taken-aback Belle reminded Helena she was “a part” of the triangle with Sean Stone, now coupled up with Lucinda Strafford.

Lifted Entertainment//ITV

“You f**king deserved half of that,” Belle said. “You’ve been a part of the same thing as well!”

“Didn’t know girls could pie girls?” one confused viewer asked on Instagram, while someone else offered: “The producers know there is tension between the girls so for the drama they’ve allowed it”

“I like the twist that they can pie ANYONE,” someone else wrote. “It’s making it so much more messier.”

Some saw Helena’s pieing Belle as “harbouring some type of jealousy” though other viewers were convinced it was all in jest.

“It was a joke did you not see them laughing,” one person wrote.

Helena joined the conversation on social media to clear up the confusion, writing: “It’s called a ✨joke between friends✨”.

Helena wasn’t the only taking advantage of the new ‘pie anyone’ rule as Lucinda also sought her vengeance against Samie Elishi for being too “opinionated”.

After coming under fire for a half-hearted apology to Belle, Lucinda has now turned it to Samie, but some fans saw her move as “vicious”.

Lifted Entertainment//ITV

“Is it just me or was that hard?” one fan noted on Instagram, while another viewer wrote: “Lmaooooooo the way Lucinda smashed that pie in Samie’s face, that’s some vengeance and ruthlessness.”

“Lucinda ASKED for Samie’s opinion mind you. Lucinda is pure jealous of Samie,” was another comment.

Speaking with producers, Samie called Lucinda’s pieing “the most random thing” and “a bit bitchy”.

Later that day, Lucinda apologised to Samie for pieing her too violently, saying she didn’t know how hard to go as she had “never pied anyone”.

“You slammed the pie in my face,” Samie said, reminding Lucinda how she supported her through getting to know Tommy before she went for Sean.

When Lucinda started giggling and saying she had “a lot of anger” and was taking the pieing “way too seriously”, Samie stormed out.

“You’re pissing me off,” Samie told her, then venting to the others: “She’s not a real human being. She’s AI.”

As Movie Night is next for the Islanders, Love Island: All Stars is getting ready to amp up the drama — grab some popcorn and enjoy the show.

Love Island: All Stars airs on ITV2 and streams on ITVX.