‘The Mistletoe Murders’ Renewed for Season 3: Fans Buzz Over Shocking Finale and What’s Next for Emily and Sam

Hallmark’s festive mystery series The Mistletoe Murders has officially been renewed for a highly anticipated Season 3 following the jaw-dropping two-episode finale of Season 2, which aired in late 2025. The announcement has sent waves of excitement through the fanbase, eager to see more holiday whodunits blending cozy Christmas vibes with intricate crime-solving. Starring Sarah Drew as the enigmatic Emily Lane and Peter Mooney as Detective Sam Wilner, the show has become a standout in Hallmark’s holiday lineup, praised for its emotional depth, unpredictable plots, and charming small-town setting in Fletcher’s Grove.

hallmarkchannel.com

About | Mistletoe Murders

Season 2 introduced a fresh release strategy, premiering episodes first on the Hallmark Channel during the Countdown to Christmas event, then becoming available the next day on Hallmark+. This approach built massive anticipation, with viewers tuning in for back-to-back mysteries that unraveled over the holiday season. The season delved deeper into Emily Lane’s mysterious past, revealing layers of secrets that explained her sharp investigative skills and reluctance to fully embrace her new life as a Christmas shop owner. Sarah Drew, who also serves as an executive producer, delivered a standout performance, infusing Emily with vulnerability, strength, and quiet intensity that elevated the cozy mystery genre.

ladygeeksmedia.com

Interview: Sarah Drew Discusses Mistletoe Murders Season 2’s Jaw …

Emily’s evolving relationship with Detective Sam Wilner remained a central thread, growing from professional tension to genuine connection amid the chaos of murder investigations. Cases this season included a chilling murder involving a chess coach and a high-stakes mystery centered on a stolen painting, each packed with red herrings, clever clues, and festive twists. The narrative cleverly resolved the major cliffhanger from Season 1, providing satisfying closure while opening new doors for future drama. Familiar faces returned, including Sierra Marilyn Riley as Sam’s daughter Violet, whose subplot added heartfelt family dynamics and youthful energy to the ensemble.

youtube.com

Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney on Mistletoe Murders, and Christmas | Interview

The two-episode Season 2 finale, often referred to as the dramatic capstone, left audiences stunned with another shocking twist that upended assumptions about Emily’s history and hinted at greater dangers ahead. Without spoiling key details, the ending ensured Season 3 would explore even deeper secrets, heightened emotional stakes, and potentially life-threatening consequences for the main characters. Fans flooded social media with reactions, praising the bold storytelling and calling for more seasons to continue the addictive blend of holiday cheer and suspense.

m.imdb.com

Mistletoe Murders (2024)

The Mistletoe Murders draws inspiration from Ken Cuperus’s Audible series, transforming audio mysteries into visually captivating television. Drew’s executive involvement has been key to maintaining the show’s authentic tone—festive yet thrilling, with murders tied to community events like choir performances, tree farms, and upscale holiday gatherings. The series stands out in Hallmark’s slate for its serialized character arcs alongside episodic cases, creating binge-worthy momentum.

As production details for Season 3 emerge, expectations are high for continued filming in Toronto and a return to the winter holiday window, likely November or December 2026. Drew has expressed enthusiasm for the project, calling it one of her favorite roles, while Mooney’s portrayal of the grounded yet intrigued detective has won over viewers rooting for the duo’s romance.

Until new episodes arrive, fans can stream Seasons 1 and 2 on Hallmark+ or catch reruns on the Hallmark Channel. The renewal solidifies The Mistletoe Murders as a holiday staple, proving that cozy mysteries can deliver edge-of-your-seat suspense without sacrificing warmth. With secrets still lurking in Fletcher’s Grove, the next chapter promises more twists, tender moments, and mistletoe-fueled intrigue.