Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex, has been a polarizing figure in the entertainment world, and her Netflix series With Love, Meghan has only amplified the spotlight on her. Following the release of the show’s second season on August 26, 2025, fans and critics alike are buzzing with questions about the future of the lifestyle series. Will With Love, Meghan return for a third season? What clues and doubts surround its continuation, and what is Netflix not telling us about Meghan’s next steps? This article dives deep into the latest developments, drawing from credible sources and social media sentiment to uncover the hidden truths about Meghan Markle’s on-screen future.

The Success and Struggles of With Love, Meghan

With Love, Meghan premiered on March 4, 2025, after a delay from its original January debut due to Los Angeles wildfires. The show, filmed in a picturesque Montecito farmhouse (not Meghan’s actual home), features the Duchess hosting celebrity guests like Mindy Kaling, Chrissy Teigen, and Roy Choi while sharing cooking, crafting, and lifestyle tips. The first season garnered 5.3 million views and 25.5 million hours watched globally, ranking among Netflix’s Top 10 shows in 47 countries within days of release. Despite this viewership success, the series faced harsh criticism, earning a 36% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes and a 37/100 on Metacritic, with reviewers calling it “unrelatable” and “tone-deaf.”

Season two, which dropped on August 26, 2025, continued the show’s formula, featuring high-profile guests like Tan France, José Andrés, and Jay Shetty. The season leaned into Meghan’s softer side, portraying her as a learner rather than an expert, with moments like her marveling at guests’ culinary skills. While some praised this humbler approach, critics remained unimpressed, describing the show as “boring” and “lacking charisma.” The New York Times noted that for Meghan’s fans, the show’s focus on her “soft life” is a bold act of joy, but others, like The Guardian, slammed its “painfully contrived” nature.

Clues Pointing to a Possible Season 3

Despite mixed reviews, there are several clues suggesting With Love, Meghan could return for a third season. First, Meghan and Prince Harry’s Archewell Productions secured a multiyear, first-look deal with Netflix in August 2025, signaling continued collaboration. This deal includes a confirmed With Love, Meghan: Holiday Celebration special set to premiere in December 2025, which could serve as a bridge to a potential third season. Netflix’s Chief Content Officer, Bela Bajaria, praised the couple’s ability to resonate with global audiences, citing the success of their previous projects like the Harry & Meghan docuseries.

The show’s integration with Meghan’s lifestyle brand, As Ever, is another strong indicator. Launched in February 2025, As Ever products like flower sprinkles and baking mixes are prominently featured in the series, and many sold out within hours of release. Netflix’s partnership with the brand suggests a vested interest in continuing the show to promote As Ever’s seasonal offerings.

Social media sentiment on platforms like X also hints at fan support for the show’s continuation. Posts celebrating the holiday special and praising Meghan’s hosting have trended, with users sharing clips of her heartfelt interactions with guests. One X post exclaimed, “Meghan’s holiday special is going to be epic! Can’t wait for more With Love, Meghan! #Season3Please” This enthusiasm, combined with the show’s consistent Top 10 performance on Netflix’s charts, suggests there’s an audience eager for more.

Doubts and Challenges Ahead

Despite these positive signs, significant doubts cloud the prospect of a third season. Netflix’s shift away from multi-project agreements, as seen with the non-renewal of the Sussexes’ original $100 million deal, raises questions about the show’s priority. The new first-look deal is reportedly less lucrative, giving Netflix the option to pick and choose Archewell’s projects rather than committing to all of them. This flexibility could mean that With Love, Meghan faces tougher scrutiny, especially given its critical reception.

Critics have been relentless, with outlets like The Hollywood Reporter calling the show a “Montecito ego trip” and Variety noting Meghan’s reluctance to share personal insights, making it feel impersonal. The Independent went as far as describing it as “queasy and exhausting,” suggesting that the show’s polished aesthetic alienates viewers seeking authenticity. These reviews could weigh heavily on Netflix’s decision, as the streamer prioritizes projects with broad appeal.

Moreover, Meghan and Harry’s focus on other projects, such as the documentary Masaka Kids, A Rhythm Within and a film adaptation of Meet Me at the Lake, may divert resources from With Love, Meghan. The couple’s announcement of these new ventures alongside the holiday special suggests a broader creative vision, potentially diluting their commitment to the lifestyle series.

What Netflix Isn’t Telling Us

Netflix has remained tight-lipped about a third season, and this silence fuels speculation. While the streamer confirmed the holiday special and praised the Sussexes’ influence, there’s no explicit commitment to renewing With Love, Meghan. Industry insiders suggest that Netflix is evaluating the show’s performance metrics beyond viewership, such as engagement with As Ever products and audience retention rates. The lack of transparency could indicate internal debates about the show’s cost versus its return on investment, especially given the high production values and celebrity guest fees.

Another hidden factor is the public’s perception of Meghan herself. Since stepping back from royal duties in 2020, she has faced intense scrutiny, and With Love, Meghan has been criticized for its perceived disconnect from everyday viewers. Comments on X reflect this divide, with some users praising Meghan’s elegance while others call the show “out of touch.” Netflix may be cautious about investing in a project that continues to polarize audiences.

Meghan’s Broader Vision and Future

Beyond With Love, Meghan, Meghan Markle is clearly building a multifaceted empire. Her return to Instagram in January 2025 and the launch of As Ever demonstrate her intent to carve out a space in the lifestyle and wellness industry. The success of As Ever products, which sold out rapidly, suggests that Meghan’s brand has significant market potential, even if the show itself struggles with critics.

If a third season is greenlit, fans can expect more of the same polished aesthetic, with a possible focus on holiday-themed episodes or deeper integration of As Ever products. Some speculate that Meghan might address criticisms by incorporating more personal anecdotes or showcasing her family life, though she has been protective of her privacy, as evidenced by her decision not to film in her actual Montecito home.

Alternatively, Meghan may pivot to new formats, such as a podcast revival or a scripted series, leveraging Archewell’s first-look deal. Her past success with the Archetypes podcast and the Harry & Meghan docuseries shows her versatility, and Netflix’s continued partnership suggests confidence in her ability to deliver compelling content.

Conclusion

The future of With Love, Meghan Season 3 remains uncertain, caught between promising clues and significant doubts. The confirmed holiday special and Netflix’s extended deal with Archewell offer hope, but critical backlash and competing projects raise questions about the show’s longevity. What Netflix isn’t saying—about viewership metrics, budget considerations, or Meghan’s polarizing image—adds to the mystery. For now, fans can look forward to the December 2025 holiday special while speculating about whether Meghan will continue her lifestyle journey on screen. As the Duchess continues to navigate her post-royal career, one thing is clear: her next move will keep the world watching.